Together for Justice renews its call for the immediate and unconditional release of elderly Saudi religious scholar Dr. Safar bin Abdulrahman Al-Hawali, who has remained in detention since July 2018 despite suffering from serious medical conditions and disabilities affecting his speech, mobility, and ability to care for himself.
The organization condemns his continued imprisonment for more than eight years following the circulation of a book criticizing Saudi government policies, alongside the detention and prosecution of several of his sons and relatives in what human rights organizations have described as a pattern of retaliation and collective punishment.
Al-Hawali was already severely ill and largely confined to his bed when Saudi security forces raided his home on 12 July 2018. He was suffering from the effects of previous strokes, serious speech and mobility difficulties, a fractured pelvis, and other conditions requiring continuous medical attention.
Despite knowing the seriousness of his condition, Saudi authorities arrested him during a security operation in which an ambulance was brought to transport him into detention.
His arrest followed the circulation of a draft of his book Muslims and Western Civilisation, in which he examined the political situation in Saudi Arabia, criticized government policies, and offered advice to religious scholars, society, and the ruling family.
Rather than treating his views as legitimate expressions of opinion open to public debate, the authorities subjected an elderly and medically vulnerable scholar to detention under counterterrorism legislation.
Together for Justice considers this an alarming example of how peaceful criticism can be transformed into a security matter, with severe consequences for freedom of expression and the rights of vulnerable detainees.
The crackdown did not stop with Al-Hawali himself.
Saudi authorities also arrested four of his sons — Abdullah, Abdulrahman, Abdulrahim, and Ibrahim — together with his brother Saadullah Al-Hawali and his office manager, Dr. Ismail Al-Hassan.
Ibrahim was released after approximately seven months, while his three brothers remained imprisoned and received lengthy sentences, subsequently increased on appeal to 15, 16, and 17 years.
These arrests raise serious concerns that Al-Hawali’s family members were targeted to exert pressure and retaliate against him for his political and religious views.
Instead of protecting the family of an elderly man with serious disabilities, the authorities subjected several of his relatives to prolonged detention and severe punishment.
Al-Hawali’s imprisonment has also been accompanied by serious concerns over his health and treatment.
The United Nations Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities documented his need for assistance with communication, mobility, and personal care, as well as violations involving inadequate access to appropriate medical and rehabilitative services.
Following his arrest, Saudi authorities concealed his whereabouts from his family until September 2018. He subsequently faced prolonged restrictions on family visits and communication despite his particular need for care and support.
His case has attracted significant scrutiny from independent United Nations human rights mechanisms.
In Opinion No. 26/2023, the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention concluded that Al-Hawali’s detention was arbitrary and linked to his peaceful exercise of freedom of opinion and expression. The Working Group called for his immediate release, compensation, and an independent investigation into the violations he had suffered.
In March 2024, the UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities found that Saudi Arabia had violated his rights, including by subjecting him to enforced disappearance, denying effective access to justice, and failing to ensure appropriate healthcare and protections related to his disabilities.
Despite these findings, Saudi authorities failed to implement the required remedies.
In April 2026, a UN follow-up report classified Saudi Arabia’s response to the recommendations concerning Al-Hawali’s case as non-compliance.
His legal proceedings also remain unresolved, with no publicly confirmed final judgment against him. Saudi authorities maintain that he faces terrorism-related charges and deny allegations of mistreatment, despite the findings of independent UN bodies.
Together for Justice stresses that imprisoning an elderly scholar over peaceful criticism and pursuing members of his family raises fundamental concerns about the misuse of counterterrorism legislation and the independence of the judicial process.
Writing a book or criticizing government policies must never constitute grounds for imprisonment. Nor should family relationships be used as a basis for punishment, intimidation, or retaliation.
The violations become even more serious when the detainee is an elderly person with disabilities who requires specialized care and reasonable accommodations to protect his health, dignity, and fundamental rights.
Together for Justice holds the Saudi authorities fully responsible for Safar Al-Hawali’s health and safety and demands his immediate and unconditional release, alongside that of his imprisoned sons Abdullah, Abdulrahman, and Abdulrahim, and other relatives and associates detained in connection with the case.
The organization also calls for an urgent independent medical assessment, access to adequate healthcare and rehabilitation, regular communication with his family and legal representatives, and an independent investigation into the abuses suffered by him and his relatives.
Relevant United Nations mechanisms, particularly the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention and the Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, must intensify efforts to secure implementation of their findings and an end to these violations.
More than eight years have passed since Safar Al-Hawali was taken from his sickbed following the circulation of a book criticizing Saudi policies. Three of his sons remain behind bars.
His continued detention, despite serious illness, disabilities, and explicit UN findings, demonstrates how the consequences of peaceful dissent can extend beyond one individual to an entire family.
Together for Justice reiterates that writing a book is not a crime, and disagreement with government policies cannot justify imprisoning an elderly scholar or punishing his children.
Safar Al-Hawali and his imprisoned family members must be released immediately.



